Library Ed. BBC Audiobooks America/ BBC Radio 2004
CS ISBN 0563526319 $39.95 Four cassettes
CD ISBN 0563526106 $59.95 Five CDs
For someone who once knitted a floor-sweeping Doctor Who scarf, and who cried when Doctor Who (as played by Tom Bell) was killed in an episode, any resurrection of Doctor Who is cause for celebration. Alas, these BBC productions are sorely disappointing. Although billed as radio dramas, they are actually early television programs that have been digitally re-mastered and to which linking narration has been added. I want to say it works, but it doesn't. The re-mastering does not improve the sound quality. Actors' voices become audible, then inaudible as they move about on the television set, necessitating much irritable adjustment of the volume control on one's CD player. And the linking narration is simply that--a somewhat dull narrative of what's happening during the surprising number of silent action shots. The lesson may be that the beloved early "Doctor Who" television shows should be left alone--re-mastering does not do justice to our memories. A.C.S. (c) AudioFile 2004, Portland, Maine [Published: DEC 04/ JAN 05]
Sign up to receive FREE email newsletters from AudioFile. Get audiobook recommendations and reviews straight to your inbox.